AdvertisementLB-1

Breakfast & Brunch / Dinner / Lunch / Sides

Company Potatoes

Time : 50 minutes
Yield : 6
Print
Share :
Cook Mode

Company Potatoes offer creamy, cheesy comfort with a crunchy top.

Meet the ultimate comfort food for gatherings—Company Potatoes. This dish combines creamy, cheesy goodness with a topping that crackles with every bite. As you bake, a warm aroma fills the kitchen, hinting at what’s to come and wrapping everyone in a sense of cozy togetherness. The mixture of sharp cheddar and cheddar soup offers layers of flavor that meld beautifully with the subtle notes of garlic and onion powder.

AdvertisementINTRO

The texture is everything here—soft, creamy potatoes give way to a crisp top layer, thanks to the buttery cornflakes. Each scoop brings with it the satisfying sound of the crunch followed by the luxurious melt of creamy potatoes in your mouth.

Sharing a dish like this with others brings an instant sense of camaraderie. Older adults who've savored this classic recipe through the years know its power to evoke cherished memories around the dinner table. From the inviting aroma during baking to the delightful contrast between the soft and crisp textures, Company Potatoes are a celebration of simplicity done right.

My baking dish measures 9x13 inches.

On Saturday night, I leave the potato mixture mounded in the middle and get bubbling edges around a cold center. I spread the potato mixture evenly across the bottom of the prepared dish.

Jump to the recipe card for the ingredients and full directions.

On Saturday night, I leave the potato mixture mounded in the middle and get bubbling edges around a cold center.
— Tyler
AdvertisementIC-1

Why I spread the potatoes evenly

An uneven mound gives the center a thicker potato layer than the edges. The buttery cornflakes can be golden while that deeper center is still cool.

The potatoes heat through.

The cheddar melts into the filling.

The cornflake topping turns golden.

Ingredient notes

The shredded potatoes I use

The shredded potatoes I use

I use defrosted shredded frozen potatoes, not an icy block. Loose shreds can combine with the cheese mixture instead of leaving frozen clumps in the bowl.

Condensed cheddar cheese soup

Condensed cheddar cheese soup

I use the condensed soup straight from the can. The milk and sour cream are already part of the filling, so I do not dilute the soup separately.

AdvertisementIC-7
Sharp cheddar and sour cream

Sharp cheddar and sour cream

I use sharp cheddar so the cheese flavor holds up against the potatoes and dairy. The sour cream adds body and a little tang.

Cornflake cereal and butter

Cornflake cereal and butter

I measure the melted butter separately because the potatoes take 1/4 cup and the cereal takes 2 tablespoons. The cornflakes bring the crunch, and their butter helps them brown.

AdvertisementIC-2

How I make it

  1. Prepare the dish and potato mixture.

    Prepare the dish and potato mixture.

    I preheat the oven to 350 degrees F and lightly coat a 9x13-inch baking dish with nonstick cooking spray. In a large bowl, I combine the defrosted shredded potatoes with the condensed cheddar cheese soup, shredded sharp cheddar, sour cream, 1/4 cup of the melted butter, milk, garlic powder, and onion powder until everything is evenly combined.

  2. Level the potatoes and add the topping.

    Level the potatoes and add the topping.

    I spread the potato mixture across the bottom of the prepared dish in an even layer. In a medium bowl, I gently break up the cereal before adding the remaining 2 tablespoons of melted butter. I mix it well, then sprinkle it evenly over the potato layer.

  3. AdvertisementIC-8
  4. Look for bubbles and a golden top.

    Look for bubbles and a golden top.

    I bake the casserole uncovered for about 35-40 minutes, checking for a bubbly filling and a golden topping. Both signs need to be there before it comes out.

  5. Plate and serve.

    Plate and serve.

    I plate the casserole and serve it while the cornflake topping is still crisp.

AdvertisementIC-6

Company Potatoes

Prep
25 minutes
Cook
25 minutes
Total
50 minutes
Serves
6

Ingredients

AdvertisementRC-1

Directions

Notes

  • The potato mixture gets 1/4 cup of the melted butter.
  • Bake uncovered until the filling is bubbly and the topping is golden, about 35-40 minutes.
AdvertisementIC-3

Tips and variations

  • Drain any pooled liquid from the defrosted potatoes so the filling does not turn watery.
  • If your usual dish is shallow, choose a deeper 9x13-inch baking dish so bubbling filling stays below the rim.
  • Keep the cornflakes clear of stray milk or sour cream, which can soften them before baking.
  • If serving has to wait, avoid a tight cover that traps steam and softens the cornflakes.
  • Optional variation: If you prefer a milder filling, use mild cheddar instead of sharp cheddar.
  • Optional variation: If you want a breadcrumb topping, use panko breadcrumbs instead of cornflake cereal.
  • Optional variation: If you prefer, use plain whole-milk Greek yogurt instead of sour cream.
AdvertisementIC-4

Leftovers

The cornflake top will soften

Refrigerate leftovers promptly in a covered container, then reheat gently until hot throughout. The cornflakes will soften against the creamy filling and will not have the same crunch.

Questions

Can I leave the potato mixture piled in the middle?

A thick center takes longer to heat than the edges. An even layer helps the potatoes get bubbly before the topping gets too dark.

Can the potatoes go in frozen?

They need to be defrosted so the dairy mixture can combine with the shreds instead of collecting around frozen clumps.

Should I dilute the condensed soup?

Use the soup straight from the can; the milk and sour cream are already included for moisture.

Should I cover the dish while it bakes?

Bake it uncovered so the buttery cornflakes can turn golden.

Can I take it out as soon as the top is golden?

The casserole also needs to be bubbly. A golden top alone is not the full doneness check.

Cooking notes

Nora S.

I almost put all the melted butter into the potato mixture. I kept the 2 tablespoons for the cereal instead.

Those last 2 tablespoons belong to the topping, where they help the cornflakes brown.

Caleb W.

I used a deeper 9x13-inch baking dish because my usual one is shallow. The bubbling filling stayed below the rim.

Leila T.

I reheated a portion the next night. The potatoes were still creamy, but the cornflakes were softer.

Written by

Tyler C

I develop the recipes at Truly Recipes. I cook the food I want on the table when people are coming over, and I write the method the way I cook it.

AdvertisementIC-5
AdvertisementLB-2
AdvertisementANCHOR

Truly Recipes

Coming soon

We're still cooking this one up. Check back shortly.