AdvertisementLB-1

Dinner / Lunch

Texas Picnic Chicken Bake

Time : 75 minutes
Yield : 8 servings
Print
Share :
Cook Mode

Texas Picnic Chicken Bake is a comforting, savory, spicy casserole with tender chicken tucked between corn tortillas. Cheese, peppers, and creamy sauce bring the layers together, with chipotle adding a smoky kick. Cumin and melted cheddar scent the kitchen as it bakes. The tortillas turn soft but keep enough structure to hold the layers, while creamy sauce contrasts with the bell peppers’ slight crunch. It comes to the table cheesy and peppery.

On a night with eight plates to fill, this casserole can look finished once it bubbles. If I stop there, the top stays pale instead of turning golden.

AdvertisementINTRO

I broil it for about 2–3 minutes, until the top is golden.

Jump to the recipe card for the ingredients and full directions.

Bake until bubbling, then broil about 2–3 minutes until the top is golden.
— Tyler
AdvertisementIC-1

Why I broil after the casserole bubbles

If I stop when the casserole bubbles, I leave the top pale. Bubbling marks the end of the bake, not the golden finish.

I broil for about 2–3 minutes, watching for the top to turn golden. The color gives me a clear finish cue.

Rule: Bake until bubbling, then broil about 2–3 minutes until the top is golden.

I get the golden top the bake calls for.

I have a clear visual stopping point.

I do not mistake bubbling for the finish.

Ingredient notes

The cooked chicken

The cooked chicken

I use one 3-pound chicken, cooked and shredded or cubed. Either form works in the casserole layers.

The corn tortillas

The corn tortillas

I cut ten 6-inch corn tortillas into quarters for the layers. They soften as the casserole bakes but keep enough structure to hold everything together.

AdvertisementIC-7
The divided cheddar

The divided cheddar

I divide the 8-ounce package of shredded cheddar among the layers and the top. The final portion goes over the sauce on the last tortillas.

The chile in the sauce

The chile in the sauce

The 10-ounce can of diced tomatoes with green chile peppers is separate from the ancho and chipotle powders. I mix all three into the sauce with the other seasonings.

AdvertisementIC-2

How I make it

  1. Preheat, then sauté the onion and peppers.

    Preheat, then sauté the onion and peppers.

    After the warm-through, I have the onion and both peppers together in the large bowl, still separate from the sauce mixture.

  2. Mix the sauce and layer the casserole.

    Mix the sauce and layer the casserole.

    I have the 9×13 layered with chicken and quartered tortillas, with sauce and cheddar between them. The last sauce and cheddar cover the top.

  3. AdvertisementIC-8
  4. Bake until bubbling.

    Bake until bubbling.

    I use bubbling as the transition cue; the top may still be pale at this point. The golden finish comes in the broiler, so I do not stop at the bubbling stage.

  5. Broil until golden, then serve.

    Broil until golden, then serve.

    The finished top is golden, with chopped cilantro as the serving garnish. I use that color, rather than the earlier bubbling, as my cue that the casserole is ready.

AdvertisementIC-6

Texas Picnic Chicken Bake

Prep
37 minutes
Cook
37 minutes
Total
75 minutes
Serves
8 servings

Ingredients

AdvertisementRC-1

Directions

Notes

  • Bake until the casserole bubbles before turning on the broiler.
  • Broil until the top is golden, about 2–3 minutes.
AdvertisementIC-3

Tips and variations

  • If the casserole is not bubbling after about 40 minutes, keep baking until it bubbles before switching to the broiler.
  • If it is bubbling but the top is pale, use the broiler for the golden finish.
  • If the top turns golden before 2–3 minutes, take it out as soon as the color appears.
  • If the top still needs color at the first check, keep broiling only until it turns golden, about 2–3 minutes total.
  • Shredded instead of cubed chicken: both cooked forms are listed, and the same layers and broiler finish stay in place.
  • Skip the cilantro garnish: it is listed to taste, and the casserole follows the same bake-and-broil path.
  • Leave out the chipotle chile powder: the rest of the sauce and the same bake-and-broil path stay in place.
AdvertisementIC-4

Questions

Can I skip the broiler?

I wouldn’t skip it. The casserole bubbles before the top is golden; the broiler gives it that finish in about 2–3 minutes.

When do I switch to the broiler?

Switch once the casserole is bubbling, about 40 minutes into the bake, then broil until the top is golden, about 2–3 minutes.

Can I use shredded or cubed chicken?

Yes. The 3-pound chicken is used cooked, either shredded or cubed.

How should I cut the tortillas?

Cut ten 6-inch corn tortillas into quarters for the layers.

When does the cilantro go on?

Add chopped cilantro to taste as the garnish when serving.

Written by

Tyler McNickle

I develop the recipes at Truly Recipes. I cook the food I want on the table when people are coming over, and I write the method the way I cook it.

AdvertisementIC-5
AdvertisementLB-2
AdvertisementANCHOR

Truly Recipes

Coming soon

We're still cooking this one up. Check back shortly.